Using peer review as evidence in your EB-2 NIW

Arun Asif, PhD
November 15, 2026 · 5 min read
If you've reviewed papers for journals, you already have a strong piece of NIW evidence, and many people forget to use it. In my approved petition I listed seven journal reviews. Here's why they matter, how to get more, and how to prove them.
Why peer review counts
When a journal editor asks you to review a manuscript, they're saying you're an expert whose judgment they trust. Nobody asks a beginner to decide whether someone else's research is good enough to publish.
That speaks directly to the second Dhanasar prong, whether you're well positioned to advance your endeavor. It shows your field recognizes your expertise. It also shows you're active in shaping your field, not just working inside your own lab.
One review won't win a case on its own. But several reviews for respected journals, together with your publications and citations, build a clear picture of someone the field relies on.
How to get review invitations
If you don't have many yet, there are ways to get them.
- Tell your PI or advisor you'd like to review. Senior researchers get far more requests than they can handle and often pass them on or recommend a junior colleague.
- Register as a reviewer in journal submission systems in your field and keep your keywords up to date.
- Publish. Editors often invite authors who recently published on the same topic.
- Respond quickly and do careful work. Editors remember good reviewers and invite them again.
Only accept reviews you're qualified to do and can finish on time. Quality matters more than numbers.
How I got my reviews
My first invitations came from submitting my own papers. Some journals, including ACS journals, ask during submission whether you'd be willing to review for them. I always said yes, and later they started sending me manuscripts.
How to document your reviews
An officer can't just take your word that you reviewed papers. Every review you list needs proof. These are the best kinds.
- The invitation email from the editor, showing the journal name and date. Remove the manuscript title or details if they're confidential.
- The thank-you or completion email the journal sends after you submit.
- A verified record in Web of Science reviewer recognition, which used to be called Publons. It lists your verified reviews by journal, and you can print or save it as a PDF.
- A certificate of reviewing, which many publishers offer.
- A short letter from an editor confirming you reviewed for them, if you can get one.
Keep these as you go. It's much harder to find old emails two years later.
How to present it in your petition
In my petition, the reviews appeared in my CV and in the well positioned section of my cover letter, under contributions and influence. I listed each journal with the number of reviews and pointed to the exhibit with the proof.
A simple list works well. Journal name, number of manuscripts reviewed, and the exhibit number. If a journal is well known or has a strong impact factor, it's fine to mention that too, since it shows the level at which the field trusts you.
Then add one or two sentences explaining what it means. Something like, being invited to review for these journals shows that editors in my field rely on my expertise to judge new research.
Common mistakes
- Listing reviews with no proof.
- Counting a review you declined or never finished.
- Sharing confidential manuscript content in your exhibits.
- Burying the reviews in the CV without mentioning them in the cover letter.
See how I listed mine
My CV and cover letter both show how I presented my seven reviews. You can get my EB-2 NIW CV for $55 as a PDF or $75 with the Word file, or the complete self-filing package with everything together.
Not legal advice. I'm a scientist, not a lawyer, and this post is for educational purposes only.